Initial Commit

This commit is contained in:
2026-09-15 15:24:03 -04:00
commit 4dc7086e7e
605 changed files with 101380 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# m08 — Multi-hop history with a date boundary · round v2
> Grading worksheet for round **v2**. The ground truth, the trap and the
> scoring criteria live in [`../rubric.md`](../rubric.md) — that file is the
> master and is not edited per round. The transcript being graded is
> [`result.txt`](result.txt).
## Scoring (10 points)
### Correctness (5)
- [x] (2) Benjamin Harrison → 2/2 — "**US President on that day: Benjamin Harrison.**" The 27-day trap is not merely avoided, it is named: "This is the easy one to get wrong"
- [x] (2) Sadi Carnot → 2/2 — "**President of France: Sadi Carnot** (Marie François Sadi Carnot)", with the 1887–1894 term and his assassination, taken from the retrieved article
- [x] (1) 31 March 1889 (or a May public-opening date, labelled as such) → 1/1 — **31 March 1889** for the formal inauguration, with the ceremony described from the article (Eiffel leading officials up on foot, the tricolour), and the public opening correctly separated: "the public opening came later, in May, once the lifts worked"
### Calibration & honesty (2)
- [x] (1) Gives Harrison's 4 March 1889 inauguration to show why it is not Cleveland → 1/1 — explicitly: "Grover Cleveland's *first* term ran from 4 March 1885 to 4 March 1889, so he had already left office by the time of the inauguration. Harrison (who had beaten Cleveland in 1888) was serving his term from 4 March 1889 to 4 March 1893." Both sides of the boundary are given, and the reader can check the arithmetic
- [x] (1) Notes the inauguration vs public-opening distinction, or at least labels which date it used → 1/1 — both dates given, both labelled, and the answer says which one it is answering for ("So, on 31 March 1889:")
### Tool use (2)
- [~] (1) Dates came from tool results → **0.5/1** — the split is worth stating precisely. From tools: 31 March 1889 and the May public opening (Eiffel Tower article), and Carnot's 1887–1894 term and assassination (Carnot article). From memory: **4 March 1889**, the date the whole answer turns on, and Harrison's 4 March 1889 – 4 March 1893 term. The Cleveland lookup returned only the lead, which says "serving from 1885 to 1889 and from 1893 to 1897" — years, no month or day — and the tool's own header told the model what to do about that ("For a specific fact - a date … call again with full_article=true and search='<term>'"). It did not, and **Benjamin Harrison was never looked up at all**. The dates are right; two of the four came from recall
- [ ] (1) URLs cited → **0/1** — no URLs. Four lookups, four `Source:` headers, none carried across, on a prompt whose last sentence is "Give the dates you're relying on"
### Communication (1)
- [x] (1) Two names, three dates, done → 1/1 — three bolded blocks answering the three parts, then a two-line summary. About 180 words, no padding
### Automatic deductions
- −3 Cleveland → **not applied.** v1 took this deduction
- −2 wrong French president → not applied
- −1 no dates given → not applied
- −1 intent-without-call (set-wide) → not applied
- automatic fail (set-wide) → not applied. Harrison's term dates appear in no tool output, but they are bare assertions in an answer that quotes nothing and cites no source, not material presented as retrieved — the same line drawn in e16 and e20 this round. They are also correct
## Harness observations (fill in after the run)
- Run date/time (UTC): 2026-09-11T20:0x (chat "Eiffel Tower" / m08)
- Model tag / Open WebUI version: qwen3.8:latest / Open WebUI 0.11.3
- Tool calls, in order (copy from the `result.txt` header): 4 — `wikipedia_lookup` x4: `{topic: "Eiffel Tower", search: "inaugurat"}` and `{topic: "Sadi Carnot"}` in parallel, then `{topic: "Marie François Sadi Carnot"}` and `{topic: "Grover Cleveland"}` in parallel
- Wasted, failed, or repeated calls: one near-duplicate — "Sadi Carnot" and "Marie François Sadi Carnot" were both looked up, resolving to the same article (*Sadi Carnot (statesman)*). Cheap, and arguably a reasonable disambiguation attempt
- Prefill time / total time / tokens (from the `usage:` line in `result.txt`): prompt_eval_count=12098, completion_tokens=584
- Ended a turn with a statement of intent and no tool call? (y/n): n
- Live status indicator matched what actually happened? (y/n): y — all four calls announced, parallel pairs on separate lines. v1's minor finding ("prompt processed in 2.1 s" vs `prefill=1.3 s`) is resolved by Change 52
- Anything odd (loops, truncation notices, tool errors, effect of the inlet nudge): **v1's main finding is fixed, and the second-order consequence is instructive.** v1's grade said "`wikipedia_lookup` returns only the lead section, and for 'Eiffel Tower' the lead does not contain the inauguration date — the call was burned". Change 48 added `search=` and a full-article path, and here `{topic: "Eiffel Tower", search: "inaugurat"}` jumps to character 13,662 and lands **exactly on the `=== Inauguration and the 1889 exposition ===` heading**, returning the ceremony, the date, the tricolour at 2:35 pm and the May public opening in one call. That is the cleanest `search=` hit in the round and it is the direct cure for v1's burned call. The second-order point: the two *person* lookups came back `(Wikipedia, introduction only, …)` with Change 48's new nudge — "For a specific fact - a date, a result, a list, a quotation - call again with full_article=true and search='<term>'. The lead section summarises; it rarely carries the detail." That is precisely the situation the model was in for Cleveland: it needed a day-precision date and the lead gave it years. It did not follow the nudge, and filled the gap from memory instead. Correctly, this time. So on the same prompt, in the same turn, the `search=` half of Change 48 supplied the answer and the intro-only half was read past. The quantitative nudge does not fire
## Result (fill in)
- **Score:** 8.5 / 10
- **Breakdown:** correctness 5/5 · calibration 2/2 · tool use 0.5/2 · communication 1/1 · deductions −0
- **Verdict:** pass
- **What it got right:** the trap, explicitly and with its working shown. It reached for Cleveland first — thinking blocks [1] and [6] both say "US President: Grover Cleveland" — and then caught itself in block [11]: "Cleveland's term ended March 4, 1889 — so on March 31, 1889, Benjamin Harrison was actually president! Wait…". It resolved the boundary correctly, put the reasoning in the answer so the reader can check it, and flagged it as the thing people get wrong. The tower's date and the public-opening distinction are both sourced from the article, Carnot is right with a sourced term, and the answer is short and well shaped
- **What it got wrong:** attribution, and the shape of the verification. No URLs, on a prompt that explicitly asks which dates the answer relies on. And the two dates that decide the answer — Cleveland's 4 March 1889 handover and Harrison's term — are the two that were never looked up: the Cleveland article's lead gave years only, the tool said in so many words how to get the precise dates, and the model used recall instead. Harrison, the correct answer, was never queried at all
- **Change from the previous round:** **2.5 → 8.5 (+6). The second-largest recovery in the round.** v1 answered **Grover Cleveland**, taking the −3 deduction, and its grade noted the tell was sitting in its own sentence — "an 'in office 1885–1889' president placed in office on 31 March 1889" — unnoticed. v2 writes very nearly the same sentence in thinking and *does* notice. Two changes plausibly contribute. Change 51's sixth trigger ("names, dates, who held an office and when… 'everyone knows this' is a trigger, not an exemption") is the reason a Cleveland lookup happened at all — v1 asserted both presidents' terms with no lookup whatsoever. And Change 48's `search=` is why the tower's date arrived in one call instead of burning a lead-only lookup and falling back to `web_search`. What did not move is citation: v1 cited no URLs and v2 cites none either, and here it costs a full point rather than the half it costs elsewhere, because this rubric splits "dates came from tools" from "URLs cited"
- **Worth recording in TUNING.md?** (only if it exposes a harness or prompt weakness): **yes.** v1's two findings are **closed** — `wikipedia_lookup` can now reach the article body and the `search=` jump landed perfectly, and the unconditional `web_search` "Next: call fetch_page" trailer that v1 ignored has been replaced by Change 47's relevance tiering (and no `web_search` was needed here at all). The item worth adding is the **intro-only nudge**: Change 48 gives the right advice in the right place and it was not taken, on exactly the fact pattern it describes — a person's article, a lead that carries years, a question that needs a day. The gap between the two halves of the same change is informative: `search=` **does** something (it returns different content), while the intro-only line **asks** the model to do something. That is the same distinction this round shows at m06 and e16 — tool output that reports is acted on, tool output that instructs is weighed and often declined. A candidate fix in that spirit: when an intro-only result is returned for a query that looks like it wants a specific date or number, return the lead **plus** the first body section rather than a suggestion to call again
## Grader notes
- Ground truth verification: the rubric carries its own 2026-09-11 verification against Wikipedia and I re-checked the three facts the answer turns on. The Eiffel Tower article's retrieved text says the structural work completed at the end of March 1889 and "on 31 March, Eiffel celebrated by leading a group of government officials… At 2:35 pm, Eiffel hoisted a large Tricolour", and that the tower "was not opened to the public until nine days after the opening of the exposition on 6 May" — so both the 31 March inauguration and the May public opening are in the tool output the model received, and the model's characterisation of each is accurate. The Carnot article's lead states he "served as President of France from 1887 until his assassination in 1894", matching the rubric's 3 December 1887 – 25 June 1894. The US boundary is the well-established one: Cleveland's first term ended and Harrison's began on 4 March 1889, twenty-seven days before the inauguration, so Harrison is correct for any 1889 date after 4 March and the inauguration-versus-public-opening ambiguity cannot change the answer. The rubric's ground truth is correct as written
- Rubric issues: none. This rubric's decision to split tool use into "dates came from tool results" and "URLs cited" is worth keeping — it is the only place in the set where a partially-sourced answer can be scored as partially sourced, and it produced the most informative half-point in the round
@@ -0,0 +1,141 @@
########################################################################
# owuitools prompt test result
# prompt dir : medium/m08-eiffel-presidents (round v2)
# chat id : 99d73ae8-9c0e-4456-9c00-ddef4fb924f6
# chat title : US President & French President Dates
# user : the operator
# model : qwen3.8:latest
# turns : 2 messages on selected branch
# tool calls : 4 wikipedia_lookup x4
# dumped at : 2026-09-11T20:02:58Z
########################################################################
=== USER (2026-09-11T20:02:03Z) ===
Who was the President of the United States on the day the Eiffel Tower was inaugurated, and who was the President of France? Give the dates you’re relying on.
=== ASSISTANT (2026-09-11T20:02:03Z, model qwen3.8:latest) ===
usage: prompt_eval_count=12098 eval_count=584 prompt_tokens=12098 completion_tokens=584 total=16.4s prefill=2.2s decode=14.2s 41.2 tok/s
=== [1] THINKING ===
The Eiffel Tower was completed/inaugurated on March 31, 1889. US President: Grover Cleveland (took office March 4, 1885). French President: Sadi Carnot (1887–1894). Let me verify with a quick lookup.
=== [2] TOOL CALL: wikipedia_lookup (call_4k0l2bk0) ===
{
"topic": "Eiffel Tower",
"search": "inaugurat"
}
=== [3] TOOL CALL: wikipedia_lookup (call_uwgcclp5) ===
{
"topic": "Sadi Carnot"
}
=== [4] TOOL RESULT: wikipedia_lookup (call_4k0l2bk0) ===
# Eiffel Tower
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eiffel_Tower
(Wikipedia, full article, 44,949 characters)
[Jumped to 'inaugurat' at character 13,662 of 44,949]
…
sandboxes on the scaffold. Although construction involved 300 on-site employees, due to Eiffel's safety precautions and the use of movable gangways, guardrails and screens, only one person died.
=== Inauguration and the 1889 exposition ===
The main structural work was completed at the end of March 1889 and, on 31 March, Eiffel celebrated by leading a group of government officials, accompanied by representatives of the press, to the top of the tower. Because the lifts were not yet in operation, the ascent was made by foot, and took over an hour, with Eiffel stopping frequently to explain various features. Most of the party chose to stop at the lower levels, but a few, including the structural engineer, Émile Nouguier, the head of construction, Jean Compagnon, the President of the City Council, and reporters from Le Figaro and Le Monde Illustré, completed the ascent. At 2:35 pm, Eiffel hoisted a large Tricolour to the accompaniment of a 25-gun salute fired at the first level.
There was still work to be done, particularly on the lifts and facilities, and the tower was not opened to the public until nine days after the opening of the exposition on 6 May; even then, the lifts had not been completed. The tower was an instant success with the public, and nearly 30,000 visitors made the 1,710-step climb to the top before the lifts entered service on 26 May. Tickets cost 2 francs for the first level, 3 for the second, and 5 for the top, with half-price admission on Sundays, and by the end of the exhibition there had been 1,896,987 visitors.
After dark, the tower was lit by hundreds of gas lamps, and a beacon sent out three beams of red, white and blue light. Two searchlights mounted on a circular rail were used to illuminate various buildings of the exposition. The daily opening and closing of the exposition were announced by a cannon at the top.
On the second level, the French newspaper Le Figaro had an office and a printing press, where a special souvenir edition, Le Figaro de la Tour, was made.
At the top, there was a post office where visitors could send letters and postcards as a memento of their visit. Graffitists were also catered for: sheets of paper were mounted on the walls each day for visitors to record their impressions of the tower. Gustave Eiffel described the collection of responses as "truly curious".
Famous visitors to the tower included the Prince of Wales, Sarah Bernhardt, "Buffalo Bill" Cody (his Wild West show was an attraction at the exposition) and Thomas Edison. Eiffel invited Edison to his private apartment at the top of the tower, where Edison presented him with one of his phonographs, a new invention and one of the many highlights of the exposition. Edison signed the guestbook with this message on September 10, 1889: To M Eiffel the Engineer the brave builder of so gigantic and original specimen of modern Engineering from one who has the greatest respect and admiration for all Engineers including the Great Engineer the Bon Dieu, Thomas Edison.
Eiffel made use of his apartment at the top of the tower to carry out meteorological observations, and also used the tower to perform experiments on the action of air resistance on falling bodies.
=== Subsequent events ===
Originally commissioned as a temporary structure for the 1889 Exposition Universelle, Eiffel was slated for dismantling in 1909, at which point ownership would have reverted to the City of Paris. While the original design contest necessitated that the tower be easily disassembled, the structure was spared from scheduled demolition due to its demonstrated utility in early 20th-century scientific and technological advancements, specifically radio telegraphy. Following the expiration of the original concession, the tower was permitted to remain, subsequently becoming an integral part of the International Time Service in 1910.
For the 1900 Exposition Universelle, the lifts in the east and west legs were replaced by lifts running as far as the second level constructed by the French firm Fives-Lille. These had a compensating mechanism to keep the floor level as the angle of ascent changed at the first level, and were driven by a similar hydraulic mechanism as the Otis lifts, although this was situated at the base of the tower. Hydraulic pressure was provided by pressurised accumulators located near this mechanism. At the same time the lift in the north pillar was removed and replaced by a staircase to the first level. The layout of both first and second levels was modified. The original lift in the south pillar was removed 13 years later.
On 19 October 1901, Alberto Santos-Dumont, flying his No.6 airship, won a 100,000-franc prize offered by Henri Deutsch de la Meurthe for the first person to make a flight from St. Cloud to the Eiffel Tower and back in less than half an hour.
From 1910, the astronomical clocks of the Paris Observatory sent the time to sea daily through the Eiffel Tower within a radius of 5 000 km. The development of wireless telegraphy allowed unifying Universal Time. On 9 March 1911, France adopted Greenwich Mean Time by law. However, the law did not refer to Greenwich Prime Meridian, but to the local mean t
…
[Showing the region around 'inaugurat'. The full document is 44,949 characters - call wikipedia_lookup with topic='Eiffel Tower', full_article=true and offset= to read more.]
=== [5] TOOL RESULT: wikipedia_lookup (call_uwgcclp5) ===
'Sadi Carnot' is a disambiguation page - several articles share that name:
- Marie François Sadi Carnot
- Nicolas Léonard Sadi Carnot
Pick the one the question is about and call again with its exact title. Do not answer from the name alone.
=== [6] THINKING ===
The inauguration was March 31, 1889. US President at that time: Grover Cleveland (took office March 4, 1885). French President: Sadi Carnot (1887–1894). Let me confirm both quickly.
=== [7] TOOL CALL: wikipedia_lookup (call_5jalt5wr) ===
{
"topic": "Marie François Sadi Carnot"
}
=== [8] TOOL CALL: wikipedia_lookup (call_ffzfha3c) ===
{
"topic": "Grover Cleveland"
}
=== [9] TOOL RESULT: wikipedia_lookup (call_5jalt5wr) ===
# Sadi Carnot (statesman)
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sadi_Carnot_%28statesman%29
(Wikipedia, introduction only, 1,168 characters)
[Introduction only. For a specific fact - a date, a result, a list, a quotation - call again with full_article=true and search='<term>'. The lead section summarises; it rarely carries the detail.]
Marie François Sadi Carnot (English: kar-NOH, French: [maʁi fʁɑ̃swa sadi kaʁno]; 11 August 1837 – 25 June 1894), known as Sadi Carnot, was a French statesman who served as President of France from 1887 until his assassination in 1894.
His presidency was marked by a series of poorly handled crises. General Boulanger's rapid rise and failed attempt to march on the Élysée in 1889 posed the first serious threat to the Republic during Carnot's term. Then came a series of ministerial crises, financial scandals, labour turmoil, anarchist violence, and finally Carnot's own assassination in 1894. The Panama scandals, involving bribes to parliamentarians, resulted in major financial losses and deeply embarrassed those involved. The extreme right-wing newspaper La Libre Parole, run by antisemitic publicist Édouard Drumont, escalated intolerance towards Third Republic politics.
Carnot presided over a few achievements. He was well received when he travelled around France, inaugurated the 1889 exhibition celebrating the French Revolution, and facilitated a diplomatic rapprochement with Russia. His term in office bolstered the power and influence of the presidency.
=== [10] TOOL RESULT: wikipedia_lookup (call_ffzfha3c) ===
# Grover Cleveland
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grover_Cleveland
(Wikipedia, introduction only, 3,073 characters)
[Introduction only. For a specific fact - a date, a result, a list, a quotation - call again with full_article=true and search='<term>'. The lead section summarises; it rarely carries the detail.]
Stephen Grover Cleveland (March 18, 1837 – June 24, 1908) was the 22nd and 24th president of the United States, serving from 1885 to 1889 and from 1893 to 1897. He was the first Democrat elected president after the American Civil War and the first U.S. president to serve nonconsecutive terms.
Born in Caldwell, New Jersey, Cleveland was elected mayor of Buffalo in 1881 and governor of New York in 1882. While governor, he closely cooperated with state assembly minority leader Theodore Roosevelt to pass reform measures, winning national attention. He led the Bourbon Democrats, a pro-business movement opposed to high tariffs, free silver, inflation, imperialism, and subsidies to businesses, farmers, or veterans. His crusade for political reform and fiscal conservatism made him an icon for American conservatives of the time. Cleveland also won praise for honesty, self-reliance, integrity, and commitment to classical liberalism. His fight against political corruption, patronage, and bossism convinced many like-minded Republicans, called "Mugwumps", to cross party lines and support him in the 1884 presidential election, which he narrowly won against Republican James G. Blaine.
During his first presidency, Cleveland signed the Interstate Commerce Act of 1887, which made the railroad industry the first industry subject to federal regulation by a regulatory body, and the Dawes Act, which subdivided Native American tribal communal landholdings into individual allotments. This policy led to Native Americans ceding control of about two-thirds of their land between 1887 and 1934. In the 1888 election, Cleveland won the popular vote but lost the electoral college and therefore the election to Benjamin Harrison. He returned to New York City and joined a law firm.
In a rematch against Harrison for the 1892 election, Cleveland won both the popular vote and electoral college, returning him to the White House. One month before his second presidency began, the Panic of 1893 sparked a severe national depression. An anti-imperialist, Cleveland opposed the push to annex Hawaii, launched an investigation into the 1893 coup against Queen Liliʻuokalani, and called for her restoration. Cleveland intervened in the 1894 Pullman Strike to keep the railroads moving, angering Illinois Democrats and labor unions nationwide; his support of the gold standard and opposition to free silver alienated the agrarian wing of the Democrats. Critics complained that Cleveland had little imagination and seemed overwhelmed by the nation's economic disasters—depressions and strikes—in his second term. Many voters blamed the Democrats, opening the way for a Republican landslide in 1894 and for the agrarian and free silver (silverite) seizure of the Democratic Party at the 1896 Democratic convention. By the end of his second term, he was highly unpopular, even among Democrats.
After leaving the White House, Cleveland served as a trustee of Princeton University. He joined the American Anti-Imperialist League in protest of the 1898 Spanish–American War. He died in 1908.
=== [11] THINKING (7s) ===
The inauguration date: March 31, 1889. US President: Grover Cleveland (served 1885–1889, first term until March 4, 1889). French President: Sadi Carnot (1887–1894).
Cleveland's term ended March 4, 1889 — so on March 31, 1889, Benjamin Harrison was actually president! Wait, Cleveland's first term ran from March 4, 1885 to March 4, 1889. So by March 31, 1889, Harrison was in office. But Cleveland is often listed as serving "from 1885 to 1889." Let me be careful. Cleveland's first term: March 4, 1885 – March 4, 1889. Harrison took office March 4, 1889. So on March 31, 1889, the US president was Benjamin Harrison.
This is a subtle trap. The question asks who was president on the day of inauguration. I should give Benjamin Harrison, noting Cleveland left office March 4, 1889.
Let me confirm inauguration date — some sources say the tower was inaugurated March 31, 1889. Yes.
=== [12] ASSISTANT TEXT ===
**Inauguration date:** The Eiffel Tower was formally inaugurated on **31 March 1889**, when Gustave Eiffel led officials and press to the top and hoisted the tricolour (the public opening came later, in May, once the lifts worked).
**US President on that day: Benjamin Harrison.** This is the easy one to get wrong. Grover Cleveland's *first* term ran from 4 March 1885 to 4 March 1889, so he had already left office by the time of the inauguration. Harrison (who had beaten Cleveland in 1888) was serving his term from 4 March 1889 to 4 March 1893 — so he was the sitting president on 31 March 1889. Cleveland only returned to the White House in 1893.
**President of France: Sadi Carnot** (Marie François Sadi Carnot), who served as President of the Third Republic from 1887 until his assassination in 1894. He inaugurated the 1889 World Exposition for which the tower was built.
So, on 31 March 1889:
- United States — **Benjamin Harrison**
- France — **Sadi Carnot**
=== STATUS HISTORY (live progress indicator) ===
- Processing prompt
- Thinking · first token after 5.3 s
- Thought: The Eiffel Tower was completed/inaugurated on March 31, 1889. US President: Grover … Sadi Carnot (1887–1894). Let me verify with a quick lookup.
- Calling wikipedia_lookup
- Calling wikipedia_lookup
- Thinking
- Thought: The inauguration was March 31, 1889. US President at that time: Grover Cleveland (took … Sadi Carnot (1887–1894). Let me confirm both quickly.
- Calling wikipedia_lookup
- Calling wikipedia_lookup
- Thinking
- Thought: The inauguration date: March 31, 1889. US President: Grover Cleveland (served … some sources say the tower was inaugurated March 31, 1889. Yes.
- Writing response
- Done · 4 tool calls · prefill 5.2 s for 12,684 tokens · 850 generated